We have mentioned on our other blog that Wikipedia has launched new search engine.
Wikia Search – How it Works.
Wikia Search utilizes Grub Crawler bought from LookSmart. Crawler is to be released to the open source community. Currently Wiki index is at around 35 million, pretty small, but it is still in alpha state.
“By downloading the client, Grub allows “the site owners the option of crawling their own data, with their own bandwidth. The client…is designed to connect to a central coordinating server, grab a batch of URLs, and then proceed to crawl them.” It claims 20:1 savings in bandwidth for both Wikia and the hosting website.” – Search Engine Watch.
In a sense Wikia will allow people to crawl the web for Wikia search engine from their own computer.
The jewel in the crown is the social aspect of the search, which allows all participants to edit and filter search results. When you open up an account, the keywords attached will allow you to be featured in search results. In a sense, people can see each other and connect to people with same interests.
Wikia also features FaceBook style social network, with profile pages, networks, friends list, interests and other good social stuff.
Menu bar:
Profile | Photos | Friends | Preferences | Privacy | Post a Bug
With the search bar on the top.
It will rely largely on human editing and human good will. A good comment from Search Engine Watch:
"Most of us want to search and then get over to the destinations quickly. Will that behavior change for most of us?"
Author has a point, but there are plenty of people who dedicate their free time, just for fun and the sake of it.
Wikia in the Money.
Wikia has been largely sponsored by Amazon and Netscape, of course in the hopes of becoming a prominent search player. Jimmy Whales(founder of Wikipedia) openly admits he will run ads as soon as the search gains more quality and momentum.
The Actual Search.
So far Wiki has very poor quality in its search results.
Here is my search for SEO:

With me being located in North America, I get half a page of results in foreign eastern language. Other searches resulted in poor quality as well. As a search engine, Wikia fails to live up to the name, however the address http://alpha.search.wikia.com/ implies that it is still it Alpha state.
Another aspect is the Scam. On the top of each search, Wikia features Mini Articles.
"Mini Articles" are basically stubs with links to full wiki pages. When you search for any term, above the results is a Mini Article which anyone can edit. The articles link goes to a full wiki page about the subject which again anyone can edit. I believe these Mini Articles will have tons of abuse. Jimmy said that there will be community admins who will be selected by Jimmy to keep the spam and blackhat activities out. He said payment will be unlikely which leads me to believe that it will be easy to game the system, even though Jimmy said on our call that "gaming is impossible". – Center Networks
Unfortunately I would have to agree with the author of the article, spam is something Wikipedia faced and continues to face for a long time. Having editors with no payroll can always temp them to sell some privileges, DMOZ style.
Whales stated “gaming is impossible" he is ether overly optimistic or knows something we do not.
NY Times comments as well.
“the Wikia search engine is likely to be susceptible to people who try to game the system, by, for example, seeking to advance the ranking of their own site. Mr. Wales said Wikia would attempt to ‘block them, ban them, delete their stuff,’ just as other wiki projects do.” – New York Times.
Wikia and SEO Community.
Wikipedia search made a lot of noise throughout SEO community and some of the SEO stars made their comments:
"So my reaction is pretty simple: congrats to the Wikia crew on your public launch, and welcome to the search industry! I’m glad that you’re jumping into the search space." – Matt Cutts Blog.
It seems that Matt is the only one who cheered Wikia, as the rest of community is very disappointed with what they see.
A quick recap from some forums:
"Yikes. I did a few keyword searches for my niche. The top spammer/scraper sites showed up #1 and #2 for all the searches I did. The top 3 "legit" sites in my industry were not on the first page." – WebMaster World Forums
"The results are terrible. Performed 4-5 different searches and none provided a satisfactory result. IMHO - They should have waited till they could get the basics right before launching. You can’t make a second 1st impression." - Digital Point Forums
"Not that impressed as of yet, but hoping it gets better and actually will be a competitor to Google." – Digital Point Forums
Mr. Whales seemed to be very objective and did not defend anything, but stated as it is.
"I would have liked it to be a bit more polished before hitting the public eye." Yes, us too, in a way, but that really isn’t the world we come from. "Release early, release often" is my philosophy.
Here’s something I have been telling people for a year: when I launched Wikipedia, it was empty. Not much of an encyclopedia. And in fact, my first attempt to build a freely licensed encyclopedia (Nupedia) failed completely. But one of the things Nupedia did for us as a community was give us a couple of years to talk about how to do what we wanted to do.
So, I am just following the same process here. Open source. This is how you do it. (Ever try a pre-1.0 Linux kernel? Awful!)
The difference is, of course, now everyone watches with great expectations everything I do.
Well, in a couple of weeks the noise will die down, and then we can just keep our noses to the ground trying to build this thing." – Jim Whales Whales comments
All in all – Wikia has a very long way to go, but Wikipedia team fully recognizes it. So far it isn’t a flinch close to becoming serious threat to Google’s dominance, but having a good name and a lot of dedicated support Wikia has a good shot.